Neathouse Partners logo
HR | Employment Law | Health & Safety

01244 893776

Neathouse Partners logo
HR | Employment Law | Health & Safety
James Rowland

James Rowland

Commercial Director

group of people

Download Our Free UK Employment Law Guide For Businesses

Automatically Unfair?

Employers should be aware that any dismissal that relates to an employee taking part in the activities of a trade union, or on the grounds of union-recognition will be automatically unfair. In addition to this, unlike most claims for unfair dismissal, an employee DOES NOT need two years of continuous service to bring a claim for unfair dismissal on trade union grounds. A dismissal will be automatically unfair if the principal reason for dismissing the employee was because:

  • They were or proposed to be a member of a trade union;
  • They had taken part or had proposed to take part in the activities of an independent union at an appropriate time;
  • They proposed to use or did, in fact, use trade union services at an appropriate time;
  • They were not members of an independent trade union.

Dismissal in the context of trade unions does include express dismissal, constructive dismissal or not renewing a fixed term contract.

Activities Of A Trade Union

For an employee to be deemed to be taking part in the activities of a trade union, the activity must be that of the union and not just those of an individual who happens to belong to a union.Whether or not the activities will be classed as trade union activities will be decided by the Tribunal on a case by case basis. In some cases, the Tribunal may need to consider whether the employee carrying out the activities is actually a trade union representative before concluding whether or not they were carrying out trade union activities.

Metrolink Ratpdev Ltd v Morris

The Courts have normally interpreted trade union activities widely, however, a recent case has shown that the courts are moving away from this.In the case of Metrolink Ratpdev Ltd v Morris, a company was in the process of a reorganisation, during which a colleague told Mr Morris, a trade union representative, he had evidence to show that the reorganisation was being conducted unfairly and that he had a photo he had taken of a manager’s diary which he subsequently showed to Mr Morris.Mr Morris then raised a collective grievance about the unfair reorganisation, using the photograph as evidence.Mr Morris was subsequently dismissed for handling private and confidential information that was the property of a manager. The Employment Tribunal concluded that it was automatically unfair as the employee was taking part in the activities of an independent trade union by storing information on their behalf.

The Employment Appeals Tribunal disagreed

The judge stated that the reason for the dismissal was because of the handling of private and confidential information that was unlawfully obtained. This case demonstrates that if such activities are carried out dishonestly or in bad faith, trade unionists will not be afforded protection from dismissal in law.In practice, dismissals in relation to trade union membership are very rare, due to the protection unionists receive in law.

Neathouse Partners Newsletter

Join 7,494 business owners and HR practitioners keeping ‘in the know’ with the latest HR,  Employment Law & Health and Safety developments.

About The Author.

Lifeguard applying sunscreen
Health and Safety

Creating a sun safe workplace

Learn how to protect your outdoor workforce from harmful UV radiation and promote a sun-safe environment with our advice for employers. Discover ways to safeguard employees’ health and well-being while they work in the sun.

Man and woman sitting in front of a laptop
Dismissals

Handling False Allegations at Work

Business owners and HR managers are required to work lawfully and fairly when dealing with a grievance or complaints. This process becomes more complicated however if an employee is making false allegations at work. A

About Neathouse Partners

Neathouse Partners is a dedicated group of seasoned Employment Lawyers, HR Consultants, and Health and Safety specialists, offering businesses comprehensive outsourced HR services, expert employment law advice, and reliable health & safety solutions.

With a focus on client success, our skilled team delivers tailored support to help businesses navigate complex workplace challenges and maintain compliance with relevant regulations.

Discover our solutions

Unlock your business potential

Get a Quote for Our Expert HR, Employment Law, and Health & Safety Services